(Journey Through Shoujo/Anime Review): Rose of Versailles

Some Updates:

Banagher Links and Bright Noa.jpg

For those of you who don’t remember and I don’t blame you if you don’t because it’s been a long time, I started a journey to where I watch different shoujo anime so I can get a better sense of what it is.  I watched Nozaki-Kun a while back as the first part.  This is the second part.  I think I did mention that it would take a long time and it will continue to do so.  I’m holding back once again because while I am going through Princess Tutu, I’m only watching it two episodes a week because it’s what I watch when I am on a stationary bike at the gym and I’m only on it for half an hour two times a week.  I’m like a dog that gets constantly distracted by squirrels.  When I see something new and interesting, I like to look at it.

This new series I found is called Book of Bantorra.  I’m sure that nobody that reads this has heard of it before.  I didn’t until I got Crunchyroll’s mystery box and this was the most interesting anime that came from it.  I can’t wait until I finish it so I can talk more about its unique atmosphere and setting.  So yeah, that was it.  I hope you all are enjoying my 30-day anime challenge.  There is much more to come and I hope you all find it interesting.  Now to the review:

The Actual Review:

rose-of-versielles

Watching this show and Fist of the North Star have shown how bloody and brutal series used to be.  I don’t mean from a blood stand point series that is still popular, but the mature content.  Even without showing the content themselves, people shooting children, poisoning each other, robbing people blind, scheming to take other people’s money, showing the poor aspects of society, and so on.  There is no random humor that is put into slow the blow from these aspects, which is popular these days.  I mean, Rose of Versailles is called a shoujo anime, but if it came out today it would be a josei.  No questions at all.  I’m not saying that how anime has progressed is bad.  I like a lot of modern shows, but I looking to the past to see how shows used to be.

(The Story/Plot)

I can easily explain away this part of my review by saying that this anime’s plot is based on the French Revolution.  We all know how that ends right?  Tragic for the nobles who sat on their money and titles and better for the commoners who were starving on the streets.  Well, this part only covers about half of the story itself.  The rest is build up.  Slow, but wonderful and intense build up.

At first, we are introduced to Oscar, young Queen to be Mary Antoinette, and the society of nobles that surrounds Rose of Versailles.   Then we are introduced to more characters and more incidents that lead to the French Revolution.   Characters that play an important role in it show up often and are developed, problems that the queen faces at Versailles add weight to the conflict by putting a larger strain on commoners, and we all see this from Oscar’s point of view.  She knows how things will turn out, which adds more to the ongoing drama.  It’s a slow build up to be sure, but it’s all completely worth it.

(Characters)

Like every other anime that exists, there are a lot of great characters.  Quite a lot of well fleshed out side characters exist that poke their heads into the narrative here and there.  You can discovery who they are and how human they feel as you watch the show because they are the stuffing that makes the show feel complete.  Talking about them all would take a lot of pages.  For me, the two main characters I’m going to talk about are Oscar Francoise de Jarjayes and Andre Grenadier.  The two are the point of view characters for the entire series.  I feel like Oscar is a living representative of the noble class of society and Andre is representative of majority of France who are commoners.  Many of their conversations represent this point of view.  Other than that, Andre isn’t that interesting.  He is the classic servant that has fallen in love with his master.  His character is done extremely well, but not in any interesting way.

Oscar is an amazing character.  Not just because she is purely bad ass, but because of how emotional complex she is as well.  From the day she was born, Oscar was raised a male.  This leads her to have an identity crisis several times throughout the series.  Not only because many people confuse her gender, but because she doesn’t know how to feel about herself or who she is in love with.  There was that one time where she fell in love and wanted to dance with her wannabe beloved, but that didn’t her anywhere or help her in anyway.  Other than all this stuff, did I mention that she’s bad ass?  She is a top ranked sword fighter, marks(wo)men, and a great commander.  She knows how to get respect from people that have never given respect to anybody or anything else before.  She also looks stunning in a military uniform, which has been commented on by many palace males and females alike.

(Art/Animation/Sound)

Keep in mind that this show is from the 1970’s.  This means that there is a lot of still frames, repeated bits of animation, and characters seemingly teleporting around because of the lack of animation.  None of this takes away from the characters or the story of Rose of Versailles.  In fact, the sword fighting doesn’t require high bits of animation because the characters have to barely move in order to fight.  And from time to time, there are some incredibly well animated segments of this show, but they are few and far in-between anything else.  There are a lot of amazing still frames from the end of scenes that deserve to be paintings in museum or something.  They add so much drama and character expression in a single frame and it’s amazing.  I honestly wish they did more of this in anime today.

The soundtrack is very 70’s also.  I mean, I can easily compare it to the Mobile Suit Gundam soundtrack at certain points.  There are a lot of techno bits that sound Disco in some ways, but there are some songs that are very pretty and you can listen to a million times without tiring of it.   It’s a completely mixed bag.

(Other flaws worth mentioning)

There are three major in this show that I think people should take notice of.  First there is the beginning.  Rose of Versailles has a very slow start and it takes five or so episodes before everything kicks off.  Second is the passage of time.  It’s very choppy and I wish they didn’t mention how many years passed between each event and let it progress naturally.  Lastly, the ending feels disjointed from the rest of the show.  This is due to Oscar changing locations and makes me wonder how Marie Antoinette changed so much since the last time we saw her.  It was a great ending, but it just doesn’t feel right.

(Final Thoughts)

Rose of Versailles is a tragedy that is worth watching.  It is a little slow and the show is more build than anything else, but you will learn to love these characters anyway.  I watched this series two episodes a week, which is how I recommend anybody else to watch this show.  Let the show sink in to your mind and thoughts over time.  With all the drama and everything that causes depression going on, it’s better this way.

Yes it is from the 1970’s and the animation and art are lacking, but don’t watch the show for those aspects.  Watch it for the characters and the story.  If you do that, you should be fine watching it all the way through.  Trust me.

5 Comments Add yours

  1. *sings* Let’s get down to business, to defeat, [the shoujo anime!] huh!

    I’m a goofball. Now that that’s out of the way…

    I think it’s really fun that you’re watching shoujo anime a little at a time to get a feel for the genre. As someone who fangirls almost exclusively in this area (I did say “almost,” but I mean, come on: shoujothoughts), I always get excited when someone takes interest in the either truly amazing or so-bad-they’re-good titles that gather under the heading. I mean, yeah, some are just okay, but even the bad ones let you sophisticatedly sip a glass of wine and relax on the sofa while watching the screen and SCREAMING at the protagonist to, “LOOK AT YOUR LIFE. LOOK AT YOUR CHOICES,” or “HE PUT YOU IN A CAGE. THAT IS NOT NORMAL AND ALSO ILLEGAL. WHAT ARE YOU DOING!?” (Not that last one? No? Just me? Oh, well, I stumbled across my first yandere the other day, you understand…)

    Anyway, back to your post. I have honestly never seen “Rose of Versailles,” but your review does make it sound like it would be classified as more of a josei nowadays, especially if the main character is struggling against gender norms or expectations. Shoujo heroines that I’ve seen tend to embrace their femininity and fit well into those stereotypes. (This is not always true. Take Haruhi from “OHSHC.” You’ve seen Ouran, right?) If it’s darker and gritter—say something like “Nana,”—then it’s probably more of a josei. Shoujos often have bishonen. Shoujos often set things up for the heroine to get “rescued” or “saved” or “assisted” by a bishie. Romance is idealized, and endings are usually happy or at least fairly satisfying to the girly sensibilities. (Again, please note “usually.” Have you seen “Hakuouki?” It’s one of my favorites, but it’s based on true history and so… endings are endings, man.)

    Also, is the show really from the 70s? *looks at the art* Nope, nope, I am not surprised. The old art might be a turn off, but if someone watches it for characters and plot like you said… I mean, I watched “Boys Over Flowers” eventually and enjoyed it, even though the animation turned me off the show in episode 1 during my first attempt. Maybe I should look into this, if only to satisfy my curiosity. Of course, I’m doing a watch along for UtaPri and DiaLovers soon, currently working through OHSHC…and I’m going to watch “Tsubasa” if I ever have time in my life again… I don’t know that the plot really works for me as a casual watch, to be honest, if there is no clear and excessive male-female romance to be found. But maybe it would be really cool? It has a legacy? *choices, choices* But that 70s disco music… and that art…

    Lastly, YOU WATCHED MONTHLY GIRLS NOZAKI-KUN. Did you like it? Did you LOVE it? Dub or Sub? I really enjoyed that show! I apologize if you already knew everything I rambled about, but if you ever want a good shoujo recommendation based on your personal tastes in other titles, just let me know because I’m pretty darn sure I could find something you’d enjoy, rather than something you’d watch at the gym simply because you’d like to finish it. (THOUGH, watching anime as an incentive to work out. I might have to try that…) You like tragedy? I got this. You like comedy? I got this. You like to scream at people for making the most idiotic choices in given situations? Bishonen? REAL LOVE STORIES WITH SUBSTANCE? Got it, got it, got it. (If you type “Bishonen” into the google bar, a picture of Tama-chan is the first thing that pops up. I just can’t. lol)

    Oh! And I’m such an anime novice, but you called me a senpai. Hehe, the shoujo-senpai! 😀 Made my whole day. (Also, the word “senpai” will never stop being funny to me, ever. Should have seen me watching “Ouran” for the first time. “SHE CALLED HIM SENPAI. OMG I CAN’T.”)

    Like

    1. Scott says:

      Wasn’t expecting this huge comment, but cool :). So if you want a feel for what I’m interested in and what I’ve watched already, you just need to look at this. https://myanimelist.net/animelist/Deathknight42&view=tile&status=7

      I don’t just something at the gym just you watch it. I like what i watch there too, but I keep the shows that I watch home and away seperate for some reason that only makes sense in my head.

      Yeah I watched Nozaki-kun and yeah i liked it. Subbed… on Crunchyroll.

      So admittedly I watched some titles, but most of them as more recentish because I didn’t become more interested until a couple years ago or so. Sometimes I’m in the mood for happy and sometimes I’m in the mood for tragedy.

      Like

      1. Sorry. I get REALLY excited about shoujo. *awkward face*

        Oh, WOW. That’s a lot of anime, man. Cool. Okay, well if you’re ever in the mood, I noticed that you haven’t seen “Hakuouki: Shinsengumi Kitan” or “Ouran High School Host Club.” Both are pinnacles of the genre for every different reasons. I won’t talk your ear off (type your ear off?) about it, but one is a romcom and the other is a historical-fantasy-tragedy. I think you can figure which is which. Also, both are reverse harem, but reverse harem well done. You’d probably like both. They are pretty universally agreed upon as being shoujo well done. (And almost everyone likes “Ouran” even if they don’t like shoujo–or anime–much, I think. It makes fun of shoujo tropes SO badly. It’s great. My first anime.)

        If you do watch Hakuouki, tweet me or something? Because that stuff is amazing and also has two equally “correct” but different watch orders and I will give you the heads up if you want.

        Liked by 1 person

      2. Scott says:

        I have seen Ouran. Not sure why it didn’t show up. It was a lot of fun :).

        And I guess I will add Hakuouki on my watch list thing. Probably watch it next after things and stuff (Princess Tutu). 🙂

        Like

      3. Scott says:

        Oh, and it’s always good to be excited about anime. Don’t be ashamed about it :).

        Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s