(Quick Reaction/Review) Fate/Grand Order: First order

Welcome to 2017, the year of Fate!  I mean that in two senses.  One is that after the dumpster year that was 2016, 2017 is the fated year to decide which way the world goes in its wake.  The other is we are going to get a lot of material from the Fate universe this year.  I’m pretty excited about the second one and much less enthused about the first.  Okay, let’s move this in a slightly more positive direction by talking about this Fate/Grand Order movie thing.  Just keep in mind that if you don’t know a lot about the Fate franchise, a lot of parts in this movie could be heavily confusing.

Fate Grand/Order has a simple premise for something in this franchise.  In an alternate reality, some kind of anomaly happened in the present day that is slowly destroying the world far into the future.  The world is running out of magic and the research facility of Chaldea is putting together different teams of possible masters to send to the past and save the human race.  Simple enough right?  Well not really, but the execution is.  The characters are simple with easy to follow character arcs and the movie itself doesn’t try to over explain itself like a lot of the Fate universes material.  I think that’s why I enjoyed it a lot more than some of the other installments.

When I say the characters are basic, I really mean it.  The main protagonist name is Fujimara Ritsuka and he is your average video game character stand in.  He has no personality and traits other than being defined as ordinary.  There is also Mash, the female protagonist who sticks out from everybody else because of her hair color.  She eventually becomes a servant (historical figure with amazing abilities) with Fujimara as her master.  There is also the head of Chaldea by the name of Olga.  She is a rich and entitled female master mage.  Fate can’t seem to even breath without those somewhere in their series.   Last but not least, there is Doctor Romani who is just an average doctor….apparently.  He is the current head of Chaldea.  You see what I mean by weak characters?  None of them go beyond these traits.  That’s okay though; the best part of this movie is yet to come.

If there is one thing about Fate:Grand/Order that is a massive stand out, it’s the art and the animation.  It’s very clear that is where the focus of this movie was.  Each set design from the Chadlea facility to the location where they are headed looks distinct and amazing.  The character designs are basic a basic Type Moon affair, but there character designs are still great and distinct.  Especially the servants because their armor is always distinct, interesting, and somehow ties together the culture of what they came from.  They are great.  Moving away from art design, the animation is stellar.  The choreography is good, the movements are incredibly fluid, and special effects are just generally amazing.  Fate/Grand Order is just a feast for the eyes.

When I talked about how I liked this compared to other Fate works, I was talking about the characters.  Fate/Grand Order doesn’t have great characters, but these aren’t character that try to pound their stupid and forced beliefs into you with ongoing sentences that feel like they go on forever.  This is the problem I had with Unlimited Blade Work’s second half.  While the first half had good characters, it seemed like it dropped that aspect in the second half in order to pound the meaning of a true hero philosophy into you.  Fate/Grand Order doesn’t do that and just goes straight into the action and fun.  While I didn’t appreciate the action as much as I could have if there was strong characters, the world building took some of the load here by giving me a reason to care about circumstances behind the conflict.  It’s not a perfect conversion by any means, but then I wouldn’t say that Fate/Grand Order is anything special either.  I just had a fun time watching it.

This jumps into spoilers a little bit, but it’s interesting that they chose to start this year of Fate with a series that ends with the protagonists having to go into alternate universes.  We will be seeing more alternate universes in the future with Heaven’s Feel, Apocrypha, and Extra Game.  I look forward to them all.  Even more Fate/Grand Order installments if they happen.  Before you all ask, I have watched Fate/Zero and love it.  It’s  my favorite fate show, though it’s slightly pretentious too.

 

7 Comments Add yours

  1. I’ve never been a fan of this franchise because there’s simply far too much info dumping and pretentious monologues for me.

    I did quite like the second half of Zero though when they finally started going places. The final battle in particular was very entertaining.

    That being said, I’ll still be watching this. Perhaps this alternate reality is the one that’ll end up hitting the right marks for me.

    Thanks for your thoughts on this. Good read!

    Like

    1. Scott says:

      I never had a problem with Zero’s monologues for some reason, but Unlimited Blade Work’s monologues are terrible. I think Urobuchi knows how to make it interesting.

      Thank you for reading.

      Like

  2. mrconair says:

    I left this going “What’s the point!?”. It felt like the last third of a movie, but also weirdly padded out. It felt like the standard magical school schlock that dominates light novel shelves.

    Also, this is a pet peeve of mine, but I think pretentious is a term that should be avoided as much as possible. Saying someone doesn’t articulate their point very well is one thing, but to insist that YOU know for absolute fact that they don’t even know what they’re talking about? That’s an incredibly bold claim.

    Like

    1. Scott says:

      I hate to tell you this, but power fantasy has been a thing that has existed in anime for a long time. Even Japanese highschool power fantasy with things like Yu Yu Hakusho and Ushio and Tora that have been around since the 90’s. Do I think that light novel stuff has homogenized this concept to where each series is the same? Yes, remembering that one season that had three shows that had the exact same episode. I don’t think that Fate Grand/Order is on that level of crap. Does it have problems, yes. Plenty of problems to be sure, but it doesn’t dip into that bucket of cliches.

      Now on to the word Pretentious. If you have read anything on my blog, you would know that in over a hundred and something posts, this is the first time that I used that word on this blog EVER. I don’t take that word lightly, but I firmly believe that at least the second half of the Unlimited Blade Works is pretentious. Why? Because these shallow characters are spewing endless amounts of dailogue in order to make themselves feel fleshed out and it doesn’t work. I still don’t know these characters, so I don’t even know if they believe what they are saying or if the writer behind it all actually knows what he is talking about. Maybe he is, but I don’t know that. That’s the difference between it and F/Z. With Zero, we spend enough time with these characters to know how who they are and how they think. When they say something, they don’t have to say it over and over again in order for the audience to get what they are saying.

      I will never say that what I am saying is the only opinion and a defined fact. I have said this so many times through out my rants, but just know that UBW doesn’t work for me.

      Like

      1. mrconair says:

        Sorry, I meant that the characters are more-or-less completely defined by their tropes. As for the visuals, they’re okay, but for me I’d say you’d need them to be on par with Terror in Resonance or (…UBW) for them to be enough. There were a good few cases of still animation here.

        As for the whole “pretentious” word, my issues are purely semantic. I know Fate Stay Night is very deeply flawed, but that’s largely down to Nasu being a poor storyteller and in general lacking cohesion and punch in his execution.

        Liked by 1 person

  3. andy1076 says:

    I found it a bit confusing in the beginning, Like a bit of time travel meets fate series but I do like where it’s going! seeing evil Sabre was strangely refreshing too 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Antalasia says:

    ” Last but not least, there is Doctor Romani who is just an average doctor….apparently. He is the current head of Chaldea. You see what I mean by weak characters?”

    Actually believing Roman when he easily organized a crumbling place in ten minutes and Lev was furious he survived. Sure he has no magic circuits and is a ‘normal person’ but at the same time he’s not at all. And ties with his mysterious past which eventually comes to light (he’s 100000% super good person, don’t worry. No villain reveal. He’s more of a big good reveal).
    Hint: “This is Roman’s story” about FGO.

    Keep in mind this is a Prologue (which also rushed things) and is meant to be mostly an infodump. The game has several chapters of varied length and quality.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s