(Quick Thoughts) The Crunchyroll Anime Awards Fiasco

I know that a lot of other people have commented and made their posts on this already.  Well, I want to share my thoughts too and they may or may not be different from everybody else.  The Crunchyroll Anime Awards was a cool concept, but I feel like it’s execution was heavily flawed.  I saw quite several problems and issues with it that should be worked on for next time.  Getting people of “anime authority”, if we have any, was a good idea, but after that it seemed like one issue dropped another.  What are they? Well, let’s consider this with while considering these issues of The Crunchyroll Anime Awards with more detail.  This is all my opinion, of course.

Starting out, it seemed like Crunchyroll had some good ideas on how to do this thing.  Get a good number of people that have some position of power in the anime community together to put together a select list of anime for different categories like “best villain”, “best boy”, “best opening”, and etc.  According to Arkada’s podcast with Miles Thomas from Crunchyroll, the judges didn’t even talk to each other to decide this list.  Their lists were sent anonymously and therefore there were a lot of repeats and questionable things to vote for in different categories.  I wish that there was more diversity in the choices, but that didn’t end up happening.  Oh well, something to fix up and improve on next time.

The next big fault was opening it up to the public without a limit to how many times a person can vote.  Unlike Anime News Network’s poll for best series of the year, Crunchyroll’s awards did not have anything set up like that.  Maybe they were thinking that people were going to use the honor roll system, but we all know that doesn’t work on the internet.  I feel like this is how Yuri on Ice got all its wins.  Or maybe that many people voted for YOI, but I can’t help but feel doubtful about that.  I mean, the polls with Yuri on Ice winning had more people vote for that show then the total number of votes of categories without Yuri on Ice.  That seems a little suspect to me.

I mean, doesn’t that look a little fishy to you?  I will never say that anything that people vote for is wrong because voting is always up to the individual, but you must admit that there is something off here.

In conclusion, The Crunchyroll Anime Award was a good idea, but was a bit of a mess this first time around.  I know I am just a guy on the internet that is running a blog for some reason, but these are the two issues that Crunchyroll needs to improve on next time.  Get the judges to talk to each other, only allow one vote per person, and maybe wait for the year to finally end before getting the judge together.  Waiting a little bit will give a full fall season for judges to look at before deciding choices.  After that, whatever happens, happens.  People are going to salty about the results either way, but this will take a way a lot of the reasons of why people be salty.  That’s it, that’s all I got.

10 Comments Add yours

  1. mrconair says:

    When I saw that Rakugo didn’t win a single prize, I stabbed myself in the stomach with a rusty dagger and fell, weeping, in a pool of my own blood, embracing sweet nothingness. I’d vote:

    Best anime: Rakugo (Runner-up: Lupin III)
    Best male character: Yakumo (Runner-up: Subaru)
    Best Female character: Rakugo’s Miyokichi (Runner-up: Lupin III’s Rebecca)
    Best Visuals: Flip Flappers (Runner-up: Lupin III)
    Best OST: Lupin III (Runner-up: Tales of Zestiria)
    Best OP: Sangatsu no Lion (Runner-up: Lupin III)
    Best ED: Lupin III (Runner-up: Flip Flappers)
    Best couple: Shirayuki and Zen (Runner-up: Haruhiro and Mary)
    Best comedy: Konosuba (Runner-up: Lupin III)
    Best drama: Rakugo (Runner-up: 91 Days)
    Best Fight: Grimgar troll fight (Runner-up: All Might vs Noah)

    I think this felt a bit more “casual” than it may have been intended to. Or I suppose that Yuri on Ice is just a hot favourite that came out near voting, but at least on ANN One Punch Man didn’t get (or deserve) a single first place vote. But it’s more likely… I’m salty that one of the best historical drama anime ever made is at risk of being forgotten 😔.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Scott says:

      I agree with you 100% and I like all your choices.

      Like

  2. I also believe that the Yuri On Ice votes were heavily rigged by the shows fanbase.

    There’s absolutely no way the show got that many votes in that many categories, especially considering how divided opinions about the show in the community actually are.

    That being said, I don’t care much for these awards anyway. None of the stuff I truly loved were ever going to win anyway, and I knew that from the moment this thing was announced.

    Even if the my favourites did win, I’d be like: “Oh. Neat.”

    I’ve never felt that my opinions need to validated by my favourite shows “winning” awards. I still think Lostorage Incited WIXOSS, Jojo and Tanaka-Kun are the best shows of 2016. I’m proud to admit that.

    Anyway, back on topic! Excellent post analysing what went wrong here. Hopefully they’ll sort it out next year and take on everyone’s feedback.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Scott says:

      Yeah, validation was never what I was looking for, but fairness is.

      Thank you for reading.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Of course, all Awards should definitely be fair, and I suspect these weren’t…

        It’s a real shame 😦

        No problem! Always enjoy your posts!

        Liked by 1 person

  3. marthaurion says:

    eh…i dont really get anything from this list, so i havent been able to understand the outrage

    Liked by 1 person

  4. I just can’t believe Rakugo didn’t win the heart-warming or drama awards. Personal bias. But yes, this anime awards doesn’t seem so….convincing.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Scott says:

      Agreed. A lot of the time these sorts of things turned into popularity contests and unfortunately Rakugo isn’t that popular. A crying shame really.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s