Fall 2019 Anime At The Half Way Point

I’ve seen a lot of complaints from various portions of the internet who I won’t name complaining about this season and how it’s not that good and I am honestly sitting here wondering how can those people say that? I feel like I am watching a few more anime series this season then I did last season and I don’t feel dropping any of these shows anytime soon honestly.

Even the ones that I don’t feel are that exceptional have a lot of charm and energy in them that I can’t help but want to watch more of them. You can make the call of whether or not I am watching with a more critical eye then usual and I’m just going to say I don’t care. I think my mind is where it always is when looking at these newer anime series that have popped up. Sometimes, I just like things because I like them.

A second statement has been going around about how this is the sequel season and it is, but I feel like there are newer adaptations and series in general that make this season feel much more filled out then one would expect. With that said, I honestly don’t know how to rank the different anime seasons this year at the moment because there are a lot of things that I can’t help loving. You know what? I’m not going to make that judgement at all. I’m just going to watch some good anime.

Ok, let’s start with my rankings for this season! One little thing, I am not adding the new season of Bananya because the episodes are only three minutes in length and I don’t think it’s fair to judge that show with full length series. I am enjoying it’s short form jokes though. It’s cute and has some very fun stories that I can’t help liking even if they are very disjointed.

A Handy Guide for how I feel about shows:

Watch These Right Now: Seasonal Favorites: Highly Recommend.

Then These Next: Maybe not as high quality as the first category, but still pretty enjoyable.

Ok: What it says on the tin, maybe preferable for those who are into the genre the show is from.

Can’t Recommend: I’m not even sure why I am watching it besides learning something from it.

-Watch These Right Now-

Chihayafuru Season 3

Since this is the one show that I am writing individual episodic reviews of, are you really expecting something else? This show isn’t for those who haven’t watched the previous seasons obviously so I would suggest people to watch those before hand. Believe me when I say that’s not a flaw, but a gift. For those of us who have watched the other seasons, season three is on that same great level of the best parts of the previous seasons so far. The best part is that it’s still full of surprises at every corner despite having a similar formula each episode. The great characters and card slapping haven’t dulled since it’s absence and I am so happy about that fact.

LOGH Reboot S2

Maybe this is the show that I should really be writing episodic reviews about considering that I have watched the original series and now the light novels to a farther point then where the reboot is now, but oh well. Looks like I am the only one in my blogging sphere watching it anyway. With that being said, I’m glad I am watching this because it’s still a fantastic space opera with powerful qoutes, good characters, and meaningfulness behind ever corner with some awesome looking space battles on the side. It’s sticking really close to the light novel so it doesn’t has as much character flow as the original, but the story is still great so it’s worth it.

Vinland Saga

The first cour of Vinland Saga had a lot of great table setting and world building. Now, we are seeing all of that work producing aces every week. Especially since we are following morally conflicted but well crafted character at the end of his plotting rope with Thorfinn just going on the ride. It’s honestly very engaging stuff. The visuals are still generally great, the messages of anti war are still there, and I can’t help but look forward to more of it each week.

Blade of the Immortal

This is a new adaptation of an older manga that is basically True Grit but samurai and despite it’s somewhat formulaic episode construction, I can’t help but find myself loving it every week so far. All the character work is pretty fantastic and while the visuals are always visually experimental and fun, I can’t recall a bad looking episode at all. I didn’t know what to expect when jumping into this, but I’m glad I gave this one a look.

-Then These Next-

Psycho Pass Season 3

After the not so good Psycho Pass Season 2 and the good movie from Gen Urobuchi, I wasn’t sure what to expect from this season. So far, I can’t complain about it too much. It’s been a very restrained mystery series that is soaking itself in the world of Psycho Pass and the Sibyl system. We also get a fun and decently developed cast of characters as well. I think the best part is you can probably get people who haven’t seen any Psycho Pass to watch this too. The episode length is strange because it’s double length which messes with the usual seasonal formula and I still have some questions about it’s world construction regarding the Sibyl system, but I still really like what we are given so far.

Gundam Build Divers Re:RISE

Here is another anime season following a very bad one and I really like this one too. Re:RISE is what the original Build Divers should have been. It has a very focused narrative with characters growing every season in very strong and measurable ways and arcs. With the way the divers and villagers of the current mission are going about right now, I feel like I am watching a season of Log Horizon with Gundams instead of fantasy rpg mechanics and that’s a very good thing. It is a little kiddy, but I can’t mark a series off for being what it is. It just makes the messages stronger and more genuine.

My Hero Academia Season 4

This is the fourth season of My Hero Academia. Do I need to tell you what it’s about? Right now, My Hero Academia is down this low because this season is still getting it’s gears running. When My Hero Academia is at it’s best, it can be measured about some of the anime running and this season definitely has the potential to do that once again. Especially with all the things it’s throwing at us right now. For now though, it’s still a good show that needs to find itself again.

No Guns Life

For all it’s hard boiled edges and such, No Guns Life is a solid cyber punk show and that’s about it really. I like the main cast because they are decently explored at this point with an ok-ly set up world, but it feels like it’s not given out all it could at this point. It’s very watchable and I enjoy it each week, but it isn’t trying to do anything ground breaking right now that gives me that wow factor which is why it is down here. (Plus the ok animation with grey and brown aesthetic, even on purpose is a little annoying in some ways.) Maybe I am being impatient, maybe I am not, but I feel like No Guns Life could be so much more.


Fate/Grand Order Absolute Demonic Front: Babylonia

F/GO is a series based on a mobile game and you can tell that with how fast the narrative moves and how characters just pop in and out. Still, the show is growing on me every week with how it’s slowly developing it’s characters and world more and more. Plus, this is a beautiful looking show from an art and animation stand point. I would honestly watch this show just because of the visuals. I’m glad there is a little more then that. Hopefully more narrative and things can pop up soon? Doesn’t have to though.

Stars Align

Stars Align is a soft tennis sports anime that has good sports anime, decent characters, and some believable amounts of emotional trauma to it. Unfortunately, I don’t think the sports and drama sides are talking to each other that well. Maybe that’s intentional considering the narrative itself with those two slowly jumping onto each other as time goes on, but right now it feels like two pieces of story that just don’t click together that well.

Ahiru no Sora

Ahiru no Sora is a sports anime centered on a short and ever positive guy pulling gang member like people in to playing a game of basket ball. There is a lot of strength and positivity to it’s narrative so far with some decent basketball animation with too much slow motion, but it’s very dragged out. That dragged out aspect almost ruins a lot of the emotional impact from it’s narrative. I suppose the fact that this series is going to be fifty episodes in length total is why it’s all dragged out. Still, there is a lot of good things going on and I really like a lot of the narrative beats going on too. If only they happened a little faster.

-Can’t Recommend-


With that, I am done with ranking things for now. As is usual, everything could change her in a small amount of time. For instance, I could actually decide to drop a show OR some lower ranked shows could just start producing some fantastic episodes out of now and keep it consistent so that they move up the ranking. Anything is possible here which is kind of scary and exciting in some ways. This is why watching seasonal shows is fun. The expect the unexpected is in full swing here.

Thank you for reading this annoying long post, everyone. Until the next post.


  1. I’m still watching F/GO, but not really for the story, more just for Type-Moon fanservice. I really have no idea why anything that’s happening is happening, but Ishtar and Mash are hot and it’s fun to see Gilgamesh doing actual king stuff instead of just fighting in Holy Grail Wars, so I’ll keep watching.

    Would you say it’s worth checking out the new LOGH based on what you’ve seen so far if you’ve already watched the old one? The original story and characters are already good, so it’s hard to imagine how they could mess it up.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Those are legitimate reasons, haha. Fate girls are too powerful and hot. I feel like I’m understanding more of as time goes on.

      It might and might not be. The light novels are good so the story staying close to the light novel is also pretty good. From a visual perspective, LOGH looks much better then it’s 80’s counterpart and has good characters, but the original embellished a lot more of the character interactions to make them less like they are written from the perspective of a history novel.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. This reminded me I need to catch up on Vinland Saga. I think I’m two episodes behind or so. I thought I’d hate it going into it but I’m absolutely in love with it!

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Definitely sounds like it is a pretty strong season with all those shows you’re keeping up with. Honestly I don’t watch a whole lot of anime that are brand new (I’m typically about 2-3 years behind) but I feel like almost every season is talked about as being a weak one but there’s more than enough anime for everyone. Just having MHA, Gundam, and Fate would be enough for me to consider this a strong season. I can’t think of a season that came out with no good shows. From this season’s shows the only one I’m actively watching right now is MHA. This season covers my least favorite arc from the manga, but it’s still pretty cool to see it being animated

    Liked by 1 person

  4. I agree that Vinland Saga is exceptional. It’s up there with Attack on Titan in terms of Studio Wit productions. Psycho Pass is brill too. I am digging the long episode run time, as it gives the cases room to breathe. I am a big fan of the franchise. Season two might have had its critics, but I thought it was okay too.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. My Hero Academia is following it’s usual pattern, it’s taking a LONG time to set up the pieces and get the machinery rolling. Even if it is annoying to sit through, it should be worth it at the end.

    Stars Align… I think you’re right. It’s got two poorly integrated pieces, and it doesn’t quite feel like they know where they’re going with either.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. That’ true about MHA and it’s obvious that the machinery has opened up recently. I’m just kind of worried about more and more machinery being attached to it all the time. It’s really good machinery and parts that I like, but I hope it’s not getting too complicated where it doesn’t function later like Bleach.

      Liked by 1 person

  6. ok

    On Saturday, November 16, 2019, Mechanical Anime Reviews wrote:

    > Scott posted: ” I’ve seen a lot of complaints from various portions of the > internet who I won’t name complaining about this season and how it’s not > that good and I am honestly sitting here wondering how can those people say > that? I feel like I am watching a few more ani” >


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s